Showing posts with label South Africa. Show all posts
Showing posts with label South Africa. Show all posts

Thursday, January 10, 2008

Interview with Albert Mazibuko (Ladysmith Black Mambazo)

Ryan Alan interviews Albert Mazibuko founding member of Ladysmith Black Mambazo.
It is not necessary to understand their language to have their message come through says Albert Mazibuko of Ladysmith Black Mambazo.

The Grammy Award-winning group from South Africa, which opens 2008 with three New England concerts, continues to make its meaning clear with joyous, spiritually uplifting and life affirming music and intriguing native choreography that quickly get to the heart of what they are all about.

"We sing of peace, love and harmony. We've always sung a message of people working with each other to find a better place for all," said Mazibuko, a veteran member of Ladysmith. "The way (founder) Joseph (Shabalala) has constructed the voices in the group brings about a lovely, beautiful sound."

Sometimes people want to know exactly what the group is singing since they vocalize primarily in Zulu, Mazibuko said. "We understand this, but sometimes it's best to listen to the CD as you would an instrumental recording. We don't use instruments, we use our voices so we want people to listen to our singing as if our voices were instruments, creating a sound for people to listen to," he explained.

Ladysmith performs at 11 a.m. on Jan. 15 at St. Paul School in Concord, 8 p.m. on Jan. 16 at The Colonial Theatre, Pittsfield, Mass., and 8 p.m. Jan. 18 at Sanders Theatre at Harvard University.

Mazibuko said that Shabalala founded Ladysmith Black Mambazo in the early 1960s and he continues to lead the group today.

"Ladysmith is from Zululand in South Africa and we are very proud of our culture and history. We sing a traditional style of Zulu music called Isicathamiya," Mazibuko said.

This incorporates a style of dancing known as "tip toeing," developed in the 1950s when the black men in South Africa were sent to work in the mines, and elsewhere, and were away from their homes for months at a time.

When they would entertain themselves by singing and dancing, the guards would stop them because they said the dancing was too loud. So the miners developed a style of dancing called "tip toeing" so they wouldn't disturb the guards.

"Our mission these past 40-plus years has been to spread our Zulu culture to all parts of the world. The best way to keep our culture alive is through what we do. The young people forget their history because of western influences. We don't want them to forget their history," Mazibuko explained.

In their travels, they have found their audience has no boundaries.

"Young, old and in between come to hear us sing. We've been told we're a great show for people who have just met and begun dating. We also have been told that families enjoy coming to our shows because everyone comes together from our performance. We seem to touch something in everyone. It is truly a blessing we are conscious of everyday."

He enjoys making a connection with audiences "and seeing in their faces how much they are enjoying what we do on stage."

Ladysmith, he said, has always delivered a message of positive thinking, of keeping yourself on the road to being a better person.

"It's easy to get angry and adopt a negative attitude, since there are so many problems in our world. But, we've always believed that you can rise above your problems by keeping a positive attitude. It helps keep you focused on what you can do in life. Yes, it comes in part from our spirituality, but it's just something that is a part of our culture."

That is reflected in Ladysmith Black Mambazo's latest CD, "Ilembe: Honoring Shaka Zulu," set for worldwide release Jan. 15.

"Joseph is always writing songs and ideas. We constantly practice them to find the right way to finish them. Since we hadn't recorded new songs since 2003 we did spend a lot of time working on these songs. As well, since it had been so long (for us) to record new traditional songs, we wanted to praise King Shaka. He is very important to our people and history."

Mazibuko does not view this as a concept album, carrying through with a theme or group of themes.

"In all of our recordings we try to convey a message of peace, love and harmony. We try to bring all people together," he said.

"It's closing in on 50 years since Joseph first formed his own group and it's important for us to show people we remain true to who we have always been. Sometimes people don't like when we try recordings that aren't pure tradition. We understand how they feel, though we still believe it very important for any creative group to try new and different ideas. However, for us, returning to tradition is very important."

As with all of their traditional recordings, Mazibuko said the group hopes that people find this CD "interesting and beautiful." "We try to convey a feeling of love of people. We try to convey a message of peace."

As to the role the members' spirituality plays in the creative process, he said,

"Our spirituality is very important to us, (and expressed) more in who we are and what we are trying to do then in the context of our songs."

Some of the songs are of a religious nature and are important to the group, he acknowledged.

"However, we know people have various views on religion and we're not trying to force our feelings on others. They can take from these songs what they want."

Many people seem impressed with the optimism Ladysmith maintains about life, regardless of the challenges that it and everyone faces. Keeping such a positive attitude is important, Mazibuko said.

"This is not just us, but all the black people in South Africa. Apartheid could have made our people an angry, vengeful population but we didn't let this happen. Of course there was some of this, and continues through today. But if you consider all that our people have endured, we've kept a very positive attitude toward life and our future," he explained.

"We knew better days were ahead and we knew we would enjoy them when they came. Of course we hated apartheid and the conditions we were forced to live in, but we didn't let this destroy our joy of life."

In the press liner notes for the new CD, Joseph Shabalala spoke about various songs on the album.

Of the track, "Iphel'" Emasini," based on a Zulu proverb, he said the essence of the message is: "Try to look past the bad things and focus on the good things, Otherwise, you'll be afraid to enjoy life."

When Albert Mazibuko is asked if it is realistic in these troubling times to believe that people will embrace this message and act on it, he responded with his own question.

Mazibuko: "Isn't it better to have such a message that can reach some people than not to have such a message at all?

"We cannot say 'things are so bad let's all just give up.' We cannot follow that message. What will overcome terrible times are messages from people about rising above the bad, about being a better person. If it positively affects one percent of the people who hear it, then it was a good thing to do. If it affects more than one, that's even better. Black South Africans have had little to look forward to in their lives, but we did not give up. We didn't feel it was unrealistic to look toward a day when we would have better lives. How awful our lives would have been if we did."

Music remains a way to bring people together, to bridge cultures and countries, he added. "Music cannot be stopped by borders and boundaries. Music is about people coming together and having an experience that will, hopefully, better their lives."

Please Visit Echoes of the Land aStore

Wednesday, November 14, 2007

Ladysmith Black Mambazo

Lucy Adams reviews Ladysmith Black Mambazo's performance in Glasgow.
Most people will be familiar with the warm, glorious harmonies of Ladysmith Black Mambazo, either from hearing them on adverts for Heinz soup or on Paul Simon's album Graceland.

Joseph Shabalala, their founder, composer and lead-singer, says their style of singing, which employs unique harmonies incorporating Christian choirs and Zulu chants, came to him in a dream. The resulting sound certainly created a dream-like quality and the combination of such powerful yet melodious voices swung between rousing and soporific extremes.

They were polished, highly professional, endearing and yet at times seemed a little out of touch, at least in this venue, with their roots.
advertisement

Vusi Mahlasela, whose fans in his native South Africa simply call him "The Voice", supported them in such a good-hearted, neighbourly fashion as to bring the audience closer despite the vastness of the space. During apartheid his protest songs landed him in jail on several occasions. His anecdotes about how he composed a particular song on toilet paper and his granny drove away the police with pots and pans, added a human resonance to the performance.

Please Visit Echoes of the Land aStore

Wednesday, April 04, 2007

Bill White reviews a Soweto Gospel Choir concert.

Drawing from diverse cultures and faiths, the program ranged from the traditional "Thapelo," on which seven male singers opened up the possibilities of harmony within the bass and tenor ranges, to "Weeping," a song from the apartheid era so beautifully sung by Shimmy Jiyane that the painful lyric was transformed into one of love and transcendence.

A surprise on the program was Bob Dylan's "I'll Remember You." Although the song was not one written during Dylan's born-again period, it was given an arrangement that paid tribute to the gospel music of North America.
Read More

Please Visit Echoes of the Land aStore

Thursday, March 15, 2007

Liberation Music

all about jazz - March 13, 2007

Protest music has a long and honourable tradition in southern Africa. In the colonial era, it began at least as long ago as 1897, when the South African songwriter Enoch Sontonga wrote his classic “Nkosi Sikelel iAfrika” (”God Bless Africa”). The song went on to become the anthem of the country's African National Congress and, translated into Shona and Ndebele, a rallying cry too for the liberation movement in neighbouring Zimbabwe. (Eventually, after the fall of apartheid, it would become part of the South African national anthem, fittingly enough.) Throughout the 20th Century, Sontonga and his successors played an important role in defying, and eventually overthrowing, European colonialism, and music remains in the vanguard of opposition to evil and oppression in the region.

Two outstanding compilation albums—Golden Afrique Vol.3, which collects South African, Zimbabwean and Zambian township music recorded from 1939-88, and Choice Chimurenga, which cherry-picks tracks from six more recent albums by the Zimbabwean singer Thomas Mapfumo—demonstrate different responses to repression by rebel musicians; the first by standing tall and laughing in its face, the second by recording explicit protest material. Both have produced uniquely stirring music.
Read More

Please Visit Echoes of the Land aStore

Seed Newsvine

Friday, March 09, 2007

South African Music Awards Nominees

The nominees for the 13th annual South African Music Awards have been named.

1. Best Female Artist Maduvha - 'Maduvha' Rae - 'Kwenzekile' Simphiwe Dana - 'The One Love Movement on Bantu Biko Street' Siphokazi - 'Ubuntu Bam' Vicky – 'Halleluyah'

2. Best Male Artist Bheki Khoza - 'Getting to Heaven Alive' Kabelo - 'Exodus' Musa Manzini - 'Simply Life' Paul Hanmer - 'Accused No.1 Nelson Mandela' Vusi Mahlasela - 'Naledi Ya Tsela'

3. Best Duo/Group Cassette - 'Welcome Back to Earth' Grassroots - 'African Moods' Mafikizolo - 'Six Mabone' Shwi No Mtekhala - 'Angimazi Ubaba' Trompies - 'Can't Touch This'

4. Best Newcomer Lesego – 'MyMusic' Lucas Senyatso - 'All of Me' Maduvha - 'Maduvha' Rae - 'Kwenzekile' Siphokazi - 'Ubuntu Bam'

5. Album of the Year Bheki Khoza - 'Getting to Heaven Alive' DJ Sbu - 'Y-lens Vol. 1' Simphiwe Dana - 'The One Love Movement on Bantu Biko Street' Siphokazi - 'Ubuntu Bam' Vusi Mahlasela - 'Naledi Ya Tsela'

6. Best Traditional Afrikaans Music Album Klipwerf Orkes - 'Hantam Kwela' Boeremusiek Groot 5 - 'Banjo Volume 1' Die Grafsteensangers - 'Tannie met die Rooi Rokkie'

7. Best Tsonga Music (XiTsonga) Album Themba Chauke - 'Ntsena Volume 4' George Maluleke - 'Hirwele Makhomba No. 22' Matshwa Bemuda - 'Chom Na Chom No. 10' Doctor Sithole - 'Nghoma Ya Mundawu Vol.9' MD Shirinda - 'Gama Ra Nsele'

8. Best Mbhaqanga Album Soul Brothers - 'Into Yamahala' Bhekumuzi Luthuli - 'Inkinga Ngu R7' Thokozani Langa – 'Lishonil’ ilanga'

9. Best Maskandi Album Imithente - 'Ake Niyek’ Ukukhuluma' Ikhansela No Jbc - 'Ivila' Shwi No Mtekhala - 'Angimazi UBaba' Ovezuthanda - 'Ugandaganda' Izinsimbi - 'Ibhanoyi'

10. Best Traditional Accapella Album Ladysmith Abafana Bezamanani - 'Webafana Bami' Colenso Abafana Benkokhelo - 'Induku' Pongola Home Train - 'Inganono' King Star Brothers - 'Angethuswa Izigi'

11. Best Instrumental Album The Moreira Project - 'The Journey Vol 1' Paul Hanmer - 'Accused No.1 Nelson Mandela' Dna Strings - 'Live in Cape Town' Denzil Weale - 'Symphony On Fire' Wessel Van Wyk - 'Piano Favourites Vol 3'

12. Best Contemporary Jazz Album Simphiwe Dana - 'The One Love Movement on Bantu Biko Street' Lucas Senyatso - 'All of Me' The Moreira Project - 'The Journey Vol 1' Khaya Mahlangu - 'Khululeka' Ngwako - 'Ramelodi'

13. Best Instrumental Jazz Album Sizwe Zako & Friends - 'Sizwe Zako & Friends Volume 1' FourForty - 'Us + Them = 1' Paul Hanmer - 'Accused No.1 Nelson Mandela' Bheki Khoza - 'Getting To Heaven Alive'

14. Best Vocal Jazz Album Rae - 'Kwenzekile' Simphiwe Dana - 'The One Love Movement on Bantu Biko Street' Estelle Kokot - 'Information'

15. Best Adult Contemporary Album : English Harris Tweed - 'The Younger' Johnny Clegg - 'One Life' Chris Letcher - 'Frieze' Laurie Levine - 'Unspoken' Just Jinjer – 'Just Jinjer'

16. Best Adult Contemporary Album : Afrikaans Chris Chameleon – '7de Hemel' Karin Hougaard - 'Hartstukke' Kurt Darren - 'Lekker Lekker' Amanda Luyt - 'Deel van my' Eden – 'Eden'

17. Best Adult Contemporary Album : African Mafikizolo - 'Six Mabone' Siphokazi - 'Ubuntu Bam' Musa Manzini - 'Simply Life' Vusi Mahlasela - 'Naledi Ya Tsela' Grassroots - 'African Moods'

18. Best Urban Gospel Album Not Just To People - 'Appreciation' Redeemed - 'Live in Soweto' Joyous Celebration - 'Joyous Celebration 10' Benjamin Dube - 'Eh Yaweh - Live' The Bala Family - 'Genesis'

19. Best African Contemporary Gospel Album Rebecca - 'Umthombo' Avante - 'Indumiso' Vicky - 'Halleluyah' S'nethemba - 'Ezenkolo' Hlengiwe Mhlaba – 'Jesu Uyalalela'

20. Best African Traditional Gospel Album Lusanda Spiritual Group - 'Ixilongo' Winnie Mashaba - 'Thola Ngwaneso' Solly Moholo - 'Ba Mo Kobile Kerekeng' Sipho Makhabane - 'Indawo' Jabu & Sipho - 'Send your Fire'

21. Best Traditional African Accapella Gospel Album Old Time Religion Quartet - 'Nkosi Ngiphe Ukholo' Amadodana Ase Wesile - 'Ke Na Le Modisa' Thulani Manana - 'Impi Kasathane' Blessings of Christ - 'Izono Zomuntu' Amadodane Ase Postile - 'Moya Oyingcwele'

22. Best Pop/Rock Gospel Album Jam On Tuesday - 'Scratching the Surface' MiC - 'Snapshot' Trusted Silence - 'Because of You'

23. Best Kiddies Album : Afrikaans Carike Keuzenkamp - 'Carike in Kinderland 4' Various - 'Kersfees vir Kinders' Steve Hofmeyr - 'Laaities & Ladies'

24. Best Country Music Album Die Campbells - 'Vat my Vas' Ray Dylan - 'Hokaai Stoppie Lorrie' Fredi Nest - 'Hey DJ'

25. Best Rock Album : English J – '{Clo.sure)' Wonderboom - 'City of Gold' Chris Letcher - 'Frieze' Cassette - 'Welcome Back to Earth' Just Jinjer – 'Just Jinjer'

26. Best Rock Album : Afrikaans Fokofpolisiekar - 'Swanesang' Valiant Swart - 'Horisontaal' Carle van Deventer - 'Vyf Ster Suicide Hotel' Jan Blohm - 'Groen Trui' Albert de Wet - 'Dagboek van ’n Dromer'

27. Best Alternative Music Album Chris Chameleon - 'Shine' Lark - 'Razbliuto' The Sick-Leaves - 'Tunnel Vision' Martin Rocka - 'Through Sick and Sin' Prankster - 'Bravo'

28. Best Pop Album : English Jamali - 'Yours Fatally' NKD - 'Whats that Noise' Dr Victor - 'When Somebody Loves you Back' Danny K - 'This is my Time' Cassette - 'Welcome Back to Earth'

29. Best Pop Album : Afrikaans Kurt Darren - 'Lekker Lekker' Pieter Koen - 'Tattoo' Robbie Wessels - 'Halley se Komeet' Amor Vittone - 'Voluit' Eden - 'Eden'

30. Best Pop Album : African Mafikizolo - 'Six Mabone' Puleng - 'Thaba Tshoeu' Kelly Khumalo - 'Itshitshi' Lesego - 'Mymusic' Joe Nina - 'Travel the Gravel'

31. Best Urban Pop Album Maduvha - 'Maduvha' Morafe - 'A Ene: The Revelation' Jozi - 'Muthland Crunk' Lesego – 'MyMusic' Jamali - 'Yours Fatally'

32. Best Dance Album : Afrikaans Desmond Wells - 'Heeltyd Speeltyd' Kurt Darren - 'Lekker Lekker' Hi-5 - 'Versoeking' David Fourie - 'Kom hier na my toe' Ray Dylan - 'Hokaai Stoppie Lorrie'

33. Best Urban Dance Album Revolution - '4 U' Shana - 'Iyo Londaba' Dj Cleo - 'Eskhaleni Zone 3' Dr Duda & Dr M-bee - 'House Prescriptions' Dj Sbu - 'Y-lens Vol. 1'

34. Best R&B/Soul Album Noss - 'Versatile' Gugu Shezi – 'GuguLam’' Swazi Dlamini - 'Dance with me' Danny K - 'This is my Time' Claire Phillips - 'Say my Name'

35. Best Rap Album Proverb - 'Manuscript' Flabba - 'Nkuli vs Flabba' Zubz - 'Headphone Music in a Parallel World' Tumi - 'Music From my Good Eye' Tumi and the Volume – 'Tumi and the Volume'

36. Best Kwaito Album Kabelo - 'Exodus' Thebe - 'Tha Rocka' Sgonondo - 'Amadragon' L’vovo - 'Derango' Trompies - 'Can't Touch This'

37. Best Music Video Rolisizwe Nikiwe - Mafikizolo - 'O Tswa Kae' Marcell Mouton - Hip Hop Pantsula - 'Tlhabane yo Maftown' Lianne Cox- Lebo - 'Brand New Day' Claudio Pavan - The Parlotones - 'Dragonflies & Astronauts' Lara Hollis - Lira - 'Feel Good'

38. Best Live DVD Soweto Gospel Choir - 'Blessed Live in Concert' Ringo - 'Ringo Live 2' 1st Project - 'Play it to Break it' Hugh Masekela - 'Live at the Market Theatre' Nicholis Louw - 'Rock Daai Lyfie Live'

39. Best Compilation DVD Deborah - 'Best of' Arthur - 'Best of Arthur' Ringo - 'Love Songs' Oliver Mtukudzi - 'Wonai' Mafikizolo - 'The Hits'

40. Best Producer Bheki Khoza (Simphiwe Dana - 'The One Love on Bantu Biko Street') Lawrence Majiza (Siphokazi - 'Ubuntu Bam') Ringo Madlingozi (Ringo - 'Ndim Lo') Moreira Chonguica and Mark Fransmar (The Moreira Project - 'The Journey Vol 1') Lloyd Ross (Vusi Mahlasela - 'Naledi Ya Tsela')

41. Best Engineer Dave Segal (Lucky Dube - 'Respect') Robin Walsh (Véronique - 'As I Am') Lloyd Ross (Vusi Mahlasela - 'Naledi Ya Tsela') Deen Gillan & Richard Mitchell (Khaya Mahlangu - 'Khululeka') Dave Reynolds (Grassroots - 'African Moods')

Please Visit Echoes of the Land aStore

Wednesday, March 07, 2007

Review: The Rough Guide to the Music of South Africa

South Africa has fostered its own musical traditions since long before the earliest days of the colonial era, but the 20th Century saw an explosion of new styles and their widespread documentation on record.

The mass relocation of rural blacks to urban areas, where they sought mining and service jobs, led to the establishment of poor township communities and the concomitant development of iscathamiya, maskanda and marabi, then later on kwela, mbaqanga, contemporary gospel and kwaito—the latter a fascinating, massively hybridized style characterized by rapped lyrics, swaggering hip-hop attitude, house beats and production, and huge popularity among the urban poor in places like Soweto.
Read More
Please Visit Echoes of the Land aStore

Tuesday, February 27, 2007

One Love - Johnny Clegg

South African musician Johnny Clegg, who's popularly known as the 'White Zulu,' has released a new solo album, featuring a song about Zimbabwe. The CD, called "One Love", features a track critical of President Robert Mugabe's administration. It's entitled "The Revolution will eat its children"

In the song, Clegg specifically denounces the political and economic crisis in Zimbabwe. In an interview with South Africa's Mail and Guardian Newspaper, Clegg states that the song is open criticism of Mugabe's government. In the interview, Clegg adds that while culture should never be used as a weapon because that would reduce cultural value, musicians and other performers have a duty to draw attention to injustice.

In addition, Clegg says "The Revolution Will Eat its Children" is about the "inability of certain African leaders to relinquish power, despite its being time to do so."
Read More

Please Visit Echoes of the Land aStore

Monday, February 26, 2007

Interview with Johnny Clegg

Gazette: Your father took you into the townships when you were 9. What was it about that culture that you seemed to connect with at such a young age?

Clegg: It was more the way he connected with it. He was a crime reporter and he had connected with the most crazy, colourful groups of people in the underworld, but also connected to music, connected to key figures of the community, so he operated as a journalist, writing and interacting with these people. And he was also somebody who wanted to communicate that people were living these amazing lives in the townships. These lives were absolutely incredible - the intensity, the colour, the texture, the paradoxes, the inability to resolve conflicting loyalties. All of this stuff was communicated to me at the age of 7, 8, 9, 10. I became, I suppose, infected with the same passion and interest. It was about real people struggling to overcome real problems, real contradictions. And South Africa was such a contradictory society in the 60s. It was forcefully separated on the one hand, but on the other hand, people would meet at drinking houses, at clubs ...

The African population itself was going through a huge transformation from the rural, tribal world to the modern, urban Western world. And all of these fascinating paradoxes .... part of apartheid's huge negative image abroad was the government's attempt to stop urbanization. They didn't want black people in the cities. They wanted to have what they called feeder locations outside of the white areas. So a southwest township, which later became Soweto, was one of these big feeder populations, which were not supposed to be permanent. They were supposed to be returned...every 11 months, you had to go back to the rural area where you came, get a new labour contract and come back again to Johannesburg. The only problem is, you had people born in Soweto, who never, ever ... you had second and third generation Sowetans, and the government had to accept that this was now permanent dwellings, a permanent city.

These are all the contradictions and all the ironies that the country threw up, and (my father) was interested in that. And he was also a bit of a lunatic, because he would take me to places that were just ...I remember once going with him to...he was covering a feud between two groups in an African church. A young preacher had broken away from the main preacher. I have a very clear recollection of these two groups standing dressed in their Sunday best with rocks in their hands, ready to throw stones. And my dad put me into a police van while he went out to take photographs. And the police guy said to him, "Are you mad? How can you bring a 9-year-old kid?" And my dad was just a total newshound. He said "Don't worry, don't worry. You can sit him in the van. He's done this before. He knows what's going on. You do your job. I'll do my job. You're sitting in the police van. It's no big deal. I'm not going to take this kid back and lose the story." And he just talked his way through it. And I sat in a van and watched these events unfold and how the police went in and separated the groups and he got his story, he got his photographs - and, in a way, I felt like this curtain was always being moved away for me to see the other side of South Africa - by him. It was always this magic ... these moments. And then the curtain was closed because you'd go back into a white area, back into a white school, back into ... you know ... during the week. And so I think I always knew that there was another reality on the other side of town, which, I think, most white kids didn't know. And they didn't care.
Read More

Please Visit Echoes of the Land aStore

Friday, February 16, 2007

Soweto Gospel Choir - African Spirit

The third album from Soweto Gospel Choir is called "African Spirit," a title that's more than justified by such rollicking, soulful numbers as "Seteng Sediba." But the disc also includes a lot of Western crossover, which lessens the effect of the most exuberant material. Though it makes a certain sense to ransack the songbooks of Bob Marley ("One Love") and Jimmy Cliff ("Sitting in Limbo"), such Dylan songs as "Forever Young" are ill-suited to the group, and "World in Union" is closer to Broadway than Johannesburg. Most egregious is a version of U2's "One" in which the choir, comprising more than 30 voices, serves merely as a backup group for the ever-preening Bono.
Read More

Please Visit Echoes of the Land aStore

Tuesday, January 31, 2006

Ladysmith Black Mambazo, Long Walk to Freedom

The vocal call and response of Ladysmith Black Mambazo traces our world’s civilizations from the very beginning. As a form of communication, singing has accompanied the advancement of societies far and wide. Our ancestors undoubtedly found it as pleasurable as we do. With a cappella singing providing a natural delight that cannot be replaced by modern technology, Joseph Shabala and company deliver a series of timeless messages that grab at your soul.

You can find the full review here